
By Michael Smith | Reflective MVS
November 15, 2026 | Reflective Breakdowns
I swear, sometimes America makes it hard to tell whether we're living through a civil rights reckoning or watching somebody pitch a reality show nobody asked for.
Because apparently, in 2026, you can get caught on camera making monkey noises outside the home of Black college students, face public criticism, and somehow end up at the center of a six-figure fundraising campaign.
Not for the students who were targeted.
Not for a scholarship addressing racial discrimination.
Not for some grand effort to make college campuses safer for everybody.
Nope. We're raising money for someone accused of doing the mocking.
And before somebody starts warming up their keyboard to explain free speech to me, I know what free speech is. I also know the difference between having the right to say something and deserving a financial reward for saying it.
Those are two very different conversations.
What makes this particular story even more interesting is where it's happening.
Mississippi.
Yes, that Mississippi. The state that just elected Scott Colom, its first Black U.S. senator since Reconstruction, while another corner of the country was busy turning racist behavior at Ole Miss into a fundraising opportunity.
If that doesn't tell you something about the contradictions of America, I don't know what will.
Three Black students. One front door. A familiar kind of disrespect.
Let's start with the people who seem to be getting lost in all this noise.
Their names are Jakiyra Metcalf, Victoria Johnson, and Kaiyden Caldwell.
They're three Black college students attending the University of Mississippi. Young women trying to get an education, build their futures, and enjoy the college experience like everybody else.
On November 6, their doorbell camera recorded three white women walking past their apartment. Two made monkeylike noises and gestures toward the camera.
Now, I've heard some creative excuses for racism in my lifetime. But making monkey noises outside a Black person's home is not exactly a difficult historical reference to decode.
Black people have been compared to animals for centuries as a way of denying our humanity.
That history doesn't disappear just because somebody decides to call it a joke.
And what bothered me most wasn't simply what happened on the recording. It was what the students described afterward.
When Metcalf and Johnson confronted the women, one apologized. According to Johnson, another continued making the gestures even as the apology was happening.
Think about that.
You're standing there explaining to somebody why their behavior was degrading, and they're allegedly continuing the performance right in front of you.
At some point, ignorance stops being a convincing explanation.
I keep coming back to something else, too.
This happened outside their home.
Not at a political rally. Not during an argument. Not in some heated exchange where everybody was already shouting.
Their home.
That place where you're supposed to be able to shut the door, take off your shoes, complain about your professors, and enjoy a little peace.
And now these young women have to deal with a national controversy because other people apparently couldn't walk down a hallway without putting on a minstrel audition.
It's exhausting.
And I imagine it's considerably more exhausting when you're the person who actually has to live there.
And then somebody passed the collection plate.
One of the women involved, Alaina Kunes, publicly apologized on November 10. She said she hadn't known the race of the apartment's residents, acknowledged that her behavior was harmful, and expressed a willingness to learn from the incident.
She also withdrew from Ole Miss amid reported harassment and safety concerns.
Fine. Let the university investigate. Let her actions and her apology be evaluated fairly.
People make terrible decisions. Young people especially. I'd much rather see somebody recognize their behavior, learn something, and grow than spend the next forty years defending something foolish they did at eighteen.
But apparently, that idea is becoming controversial.
Because while one young woman was apologizing, an online fundraiser was collecting money in defense of another woman identified by its organizer as Lauren Mayfield.
The GiveSendGo campaign, organized by Tom Hennessey and titled Stand with Lauren, had displayed more than $114,000 in donations by November 15.
Let that sink in.
More than $114,000.
For perspective, that's more money than many Americans make in two years of working full-time.
And what exactly is the fundraising pitch?
The organizer argues that Mayfield did nothing wrong and portrays the backlash as an unfair campaign of persecution. The page encourages her not to apologize and suggests the fundraiser could be canceled if she repudiates its support.
That's the part that got me.
We're no longer simply arguing about whether somebody deserves discipline.
We're talking about making an apology financially inconvenient.
Imagine being offered a potential six-figure cushion for standing your ground, but recognizing that you hurt somebody could threaten the whole arrangement.
That's not an accountability process.
That's a loyalty program for refusing accountability.
To be clear, the fundraiser's existence doesn't establish that Mayfield requested it, approved its conditions, or has received any money. The Associated Press reported that the organizer declined to say whether he'd even contacted her.
But the public message of the campaign is fair game.
And that message is troubling enough without inventing anything.
It tells people that refusing to acknowledge harm is a form of courage.
It tells supporters that being criticized for racist behavior can make somebody a political martyr.
And it turns a moment that should invite reflection into an opportunity to collect money.
Somewhere, somebody in marketing is probably taking notes.
We've gotten remarkably good at making the offender the victim.
Here's the routine. See if it sounds familiar.
Something racist happens.
There's a recording.
People get angry.
Then, almost like clockwork, somebody steps forward to explain that the real injustice isn't the racist behavior.
It's the criticism of the racist behavior.
Suddenly, we're discussing ruined reputations, canceled futures, unfair treatment, online mobs, and free speech.
Some of those concerns can be legitimate. Threats, harassment, and doxxing are wrong, regardless of whom they're directed toward.
But notice how quickly the original victims disappear from the conversation.
Three Black women were humiliated outside their apartment.
Yet the national argument starts revolving around whether the people involved are being treated too harshly.
We're very good at finding compassion when the people accused of causing harm start experiencing consequences.
I'd just like to know why that compassion so often arrives late for the people who were harmed.
And before anybody accuses me of demanding that somebody's life be destroyed over one incident, I'm not.
I don't believe every offensive act requires somebody to lose their education, employment, or entire future.
I believe consequences should be proportionate. I believe institutions should investigate fairly. I believe free speech protections matter, including when the speech is ugly.
But freedom of speech doesn't mean freedom from criticism.
And it certainly doesn't mean the rest of us are obligated to pretend we didn't see what we saw.
Mississippi has been here before. But something else just happened there, too.
Now here's where this story gets particularly interesting to me.
Because the location matters.
Ole Miss isn't just another university with an unfortunate incident making the rounds online.
In 1962, James Meredith became its first Black student after a bitter legal fight and violent resistance to integration. Federal marshals were attacked. Two people died during the unrest surrounding his enrollment.
That history is part of the institution's story whether anybody likes discussing it or not.
And we don't have to go back sixty-four years to find another troubling example.
In May 2024, during a campus demonstration, a white counterprotester was filmed making monkeylike gestures toward a Black woman.
So when Black students look at what happened this November and say they're hurt or concerned about whether they belong, we should understand why.
But here's the part I don't want us to overlook.
On November 11, 2026, the Associated Press called Mississippi's U.S. Senate race for Scott Colom.
A Black Democrat.
In Mississippi.
He defeated Republican incumbent Cindy Hyde-Smith in a state that hadn't elected a Democrat to the Senate since 1982.
And Colom will be its first Black senator since Reconstruction.
Think about the historical distance between those two sentences.
In 1962, James Meredith needed federal protection to attend the University of Mississippi.
In 2026, Mississippi voters elected a Black man to represent their state in the United States Senate.
That doesn't mean racism has disappeared. The Ole Miss incident is an obvious reminder that it hasn't.
And it would be dishonest to pretend Colom won because Mississippi suddenly experienced some statewide moral awakening.
His campaign focused heavily on economic concerns, healthcare, and the cost of living. Voters had their own reasons for choosing him, and Black voter turnout played an important role.
But his victory matters.
It matters because we get so accustomed to treating Mississippi as a permanent symbol of everything wrong with America's racial history that we sometimes forget the people fighting to change that history are Mississippians, too.
Medgar Evers was a Mississippian.
Fannie Lou Hamer was a Mississippian.
James Meredith challenged Mississippi's segregation at tremendous personal risk.
And generations of Black families have stayed, organized, voted, raised children, built communities, and demanded more from a state that has not always returned their loyalty.
Mississippi has never belonged exclusively to the people defending its worst traditions.
That's the connection I see between these two stories.
Not that the fundraising campaign caused the election. Not that the election tells us how every Mississippian feels about Ole Miss.
It's the contrast.
In the very same week that a fundraising campaign was rewarding a narrative of racial grievance and defiance, Mississippi was making a historic political choice that challenged assumptions about what the state could become.
One story reflects the stubborn endurance of old attitudes.
The other demonstrates that political change is possible even in places where we've been taught not to expect it.
Both are real.
And we ought to be capable of discussing both.
Racism didn't disappear. It found a business model.
I think there's something bigger happening here than one video, one university, or one fundraiser.
We've created an environment where public controversy can be converted into political identity, online attention, and sometimes considerable money.
The formula isn't complicated.
Get accused of something offensive.
Convince an audience that you're being persecuted for refusing to apologize.
Turn the backlash into proof that you're fighting some larger cultural battle.
Then direct the audience toward a donation button.
It doesn't always work, and not everybody contributing necessarily has the same motivation.
Some donors may genuinely believe the university is overreacting. Others may simply oppose public shaming.
But when a fundraiser explicitly discourages apology, we're talking about something beyond concern for fair treatment.
We're talking about an incentive to remain defiant.
And I find that deeply unsettling.
Because how is somebody supposed to grow when the crowd cheering them on is practically demanding that they don't?
We've reached a strange place in this country when saying I was wrong can look like a betrayal of your supporters.
Whatever happened to learning from a mistake?
Whatever happened to recognizing another person's humanity?
Or is that considered weakness now?
The three women at the center of this deserve better than a footnote.
There's something I want to return to before wrapping this up.
Metcalf, Johnson, and Caldwell have said they intend to remain at Ole Miss.
Good for them.
Not because they owe anybody a demonstration of strength or resilience. Black people have been assigned that responsibility often enough.
But because their education belongs to them.
Their futures belong to them.
Their right to feel welcome in their own homes and on their own campus should not depend on whether the rest of America has finished arguing about the incident.
And they don't owe anybody forgiveness on demand.
If an apology is sincere, that's a beginning. It doesn't erase what happened. It doesn't create an obligation for the person who was hurt to immediately feel better.
Real accountability leaves room for growth without pretending the damage never existed.
That's something we seem to be losing in our rush to turn every controversy into another political battlefield.
Meanwhile, I hope people remember that these are three young women with lives considerably larger than a viral video.
They have classes to attend.
Exams to pass.
Dreams worth pursuing.
They shouldn't have to become full-time civil rights educators simply because somebody else decided to behave like a fool outside their apartment.
Two versions of Mississippi. One question for the rest of us.
I keep thinking about the extraordinary timing of all this.
A state once synonymous with violent resistance to civil rights just elected a Black man to the United States Senate.
At the same time, a campus with its own painful integration history is investigating another incident involving racist gestures toward Black students.
And somewhere on the internet, people are sending money to a campaign that treats refusing to apologize as an act of principle.
That's America in 2026.
Progress and regression, sometimes standing so close together you can barely tell which direction the country is walking.
But I don't believe the lesson is that Mississippi is hopeless.
Quite the opposite.
Scott Colom's victory reminds us that history isn't a permanent sentence. People organize. Voters make choices. Institutions change. Sometimes the places we've written off surprise us.
The Ole Miss incident reminds us that none of that progress is automatic.
And the fundraiser reminds us that there will always be people willing to profit, politically or financially, from convincing others that accountability is oppression.
What troubles me isn't simply that racism still exists.
I grew up Black in America. I wasn't exactly expecting it to pack its bags and leave quietly.
What troubles me is how efficiently we've learned to defend it, excuse it, and, apparently, finance the refusal to confront it.
Mississippi voters made a decision, too.
They chose a future that many political observers thought was out of reach.
Maybe the rest of us should spend less time financing somebody's refusal to grow and more time supporting the people doing the difficult work of moving forward.
Because here's the thing about progress.
It doesn't require us to forget the past. It requires us to stop treating the past like something worth preserving at everybody else's expense.
And if you ask me, that's a cause actually worth donating to.
Reflective MVS | Insights Uncovered
0 Comments